Images Of Poliomyelitis » plag_home » jr
 

Detrimental Literary Structures(1)

 
 

Review Index:  Janine Roberts

 
 

By Jim West

Contact

Janine Roberts (Sparks Of Light site) is an award-winning author with over 40 years professional experience.  Numerous experts and important medical/environmental dissidents, various Ph.D.'s, including Gary Null, have endorsed and promoted Roberts.  Such accolades are a huge mystery in consideration of the following critical reviews.  These are literary critiques that assume Roberts' motive, intent, and capabilities are unknown. 

Topics are HIV/AIDS and Polio

(sorted on review date)

HIV/AIDS

 
Pub Date Roberts' Material Review ReviewDate Comments
12/3/2006 The Smoking Gun (topic)
from HIVGATE(5)
The Smoking Gun, 12/3/2006:
A Close Read

by Jim West
11/28/2009 A review of "The Smoking Gun", a falsely argued topic, a core topic utilized in Roberts' "HIVGATE", "How The HIV Papers Were Fixed", "Fear Of The Invisible", press releases, and interviews, and adapted to "The Letter To Science". 
12/1/2008 The Letter To Science(2) Rethinking The Letter To Science by Claus Jensen

9/26/2009

Claus reviews "The Letter To Science", with surprising observations by prominent dissidents.  Enclosed with this review is Gene Semon's "New Letter To Science".
12/1/2008 The Letter To Science(2) Roberts defends to Jensen 10/2/2009 Roberts defends
12/1/2008 The Letter To Science(2) Jensen replies to Roberts 10/7/2009 Claus Jensen wacks Roberts
12/1/2008 The Letter To Science(2) The Letter To Science:
A Close Read

by Jim West
11/28/2009 A review of "The Letter To Science".  The Letter was written by Roberts, edited by David Crowe, promoted by Rethinking AIDS, and signed by 42 professionals.  The Letter is demonstrated to be an adaption of "The Smoking Gun".
12/1/2008 The Letter To Science(2) Janine defends to
Anthony Brink, Claus Jensen, Jim West, and Gene Semon, with replies.
12/2/2009 Response and four strong replies; Lawyer Anthony Brink leads with a very direct summary.
12/1/2008 The Letter To Science(2) Janine defends to West;
West replies
 
1/24/2010 Final response, before suffering a stroke

12/1/2008

The Letter To Science(2) David Crowe (ed of The Letter) defends; West replies 2/17/2010 David uses other-worldly, political-religious arguments.  West replies.
Footnotes
1. Definitions of plagiarism are well stated, and thus apply as an element in a wider discussion.
2. The Letter, 12/1/2008; http://rethinkingaids.com/Home/tabid/146/Default.aspx
3. The press release for The letter, 12/9/2008; http://rethinkingaids.com/Content/QA/tabid/147/Default.aspx
4. Roberts' book press release describes The Letter; at Roberts' site; http://www.sparks-of-light.org/South Africa RELEASE.pdf
5. "HIVGATE:  A Voyage Into HIV Science", 12/3/2008; http://www.sparks-of-light.org/HIVGATE.htm, accessed 10/16/2009.  Contains the topic, "The Smoking Gun".
 
Top
 
(sorted on review date)

Polio

 
Pub Date Roberts' Material Review ReviewDate Comments
5/2004 The Hidden Epidemic, a topic on page 46 of Roberts' polio article in The Ecologist, May 2004.(1) Critical Review
by Jim West
5/10/2010 The Ecologist (article) – Roberts claims to have discovered a massive reclassification of paralytic polio epidemics since the 1950s.  Roberts provides no references, so Jim West verifies the data and finds instead, an epidemic of Roberts' "Techo-Babble".
5/2004 Reference List, supplied by Roberts for Roberts' polio article in The Ecologist, May 2004.(1) Critical Review
by Jim West
7/28/2010 The Ecologist (article) – Roberts references are extensively corrupt.
2008 Roberts' book, "Fear of The Invisible", Chapter 5, last page. Critical Review
by Jim West
8/3/2010 Fear Of... (book) – Roberts transitions out of Chapter 5 by misrepresenting Jim West's limitations, his theme, pesticides and polio.
Footnotes
1. The press release for The letter, 12/9/2008; http://rethinkingaids.com/Content/QA/tabid/147/Default.aspx

Top


Images Of Poliomyelitis » plag_home » jr

©Jim West/HARpub 2009 - All Rights Reserved